Summary, from Physicians for Safe Technology
In March 2023 the Santa Clara County Medical Association, in California, adopted comprehensive Recommendations for Best Practices for Safe Technology in Schools in order to educate physicians, school officials and teachers of the complex health risks and potential health hazards of digital and wireless technology in schools. The group examined research on the broad impacts of digital technology including health and neurologic effects of exposure to wireless radiation, eye effects, mental health effects and impacts on academic performance. Recognizing the importance of protecting children’s health in all environments, including schools, several recommendations for best practices were advised.
SCCMA Best Practices Recommendations include
PDF of full report in English with appendices
Recommendations for Best Practices for Safe Technology in Schools
Santa Clara County Medical Association
Environmental Health Committee
Feb 14, 2023
Purpose: To educate physicians, school officials and teachers of the complex health risks and potential health hazards of digital and wireless technology in schools, highlighting precautionary measures and recommendations for safer use of this technology.
The support of preventative environmentally-related diseases and public health measures are prime goals and objectives of the Santa Clara County Medical Association (SCCMA). The SCCMA encourages and supports initiatives that promote the health and safety of both students and staff in the school environment. We have previously endorsed healthy school policies to reduce pesticides and protect children from toxic exposures. In 2014 we supported the CMA Resolution CMA Resolution 107-14 “Wireless Communications Safety Standards Reevaluation” to update public standards for exposure to wireless radiofrequency radiation such that it does “not cause human or environmental harm based on scientific research.” In 2016 the SCCMA reprinted a 2014 Sonoma County Medical Association article, “What’s the Diagnosis Doctor?” by hospice physician Dr. Scott Eberle about his electrosensitivity.
Recently we have examined the impacts of wireless and digital devices in the school setting with an SCCMA Webinar “Children and Technology” in 2021, highlighting the psychosocial impacts of social media including learning, addiction and mental health. In 2020 the CMA passed Resolution 105-20 “What is the Internet Doing to Us? Digital Wellbeing in the Modern Age”, supporting research of internet and social media usage to address the “impacts on physical and mental health.” Because of the now ubiquitous and expanding use of digital devices in both informal and formal learning environments, and with new scientific evidence of negative health outcomes and mechanistic links, there is valid concern that this could have significant real-world implications on students in the short and long term, especially neurobiologically (Hu 2021; Hutton 2020; Li 2020; Hutton 2019; Kim 2019; Belpomme 2018; Meo 2018)
Health
Our organization has studied the issue of wireless technology with regard to potential adverse human health impacts of radiofrequency radiation emissions, including neurologic, genotoxic, immunologic, reproductive, hormonal and blue light eye effects, in addition to mental health and psychosocial issues surrounding excessive digital media screen time. Scientific literature indicates that the mechanisms of harm include oxidative injury to critical molecules such as DNA/lipids/proteins (Gerner, XIie), membrane disruption, blood brain barrier disruption, and mitochondrial injury with much of the resultant cellular injury occurring at non-thermal levels which are well below current standards (BioInitiative Report 2022). We have become especially concerned with the dramatic increase in the use of this technology in schools resulting in exponentially higher levels of non-ionizing radiofrequency electromagnetic radiation (EMR) emitted by these wireless devices. This results in increased long-term exposures in children who spend much of their formative years in school environments (Moon 2020). There is little to no regulation or monitoring of this technology for health effects in children.
Although wireless devices are convenient, this growing robust body of peer-reviewed research has shown that this radiofrequency radiation poses significant short and long-term health risks. (Attah 2022; Butler 2020; Miller 2019). Like tobacco or toxic chemical exposures, it takes decades of exposure, as well as decades of research, to strengthen the link between exposure and harm. Therefore, it takes decades to realize the magnitude of the public health threat before action is taken (NAS 2015). Conversely, considering so many lessons learned late with regards to toxic exposures, science, policy and political will (DDT, endocrine disruptors, flame retardants, BPA, nanotechnology and pesticides), a precautionary approach plays a critical role to manage public health hazards from rapidly emerging environmental exposures from modern innovations. (Gee 2013; EU 2017)
Eye Effects
There are also emerging scientific concerns with regards to eye damage and circadian rhythm disruption from blue light emitted from digital devices (ANES 2019). The reduction in levels of melatonin with blue light exposures effects not only circadian rhythms but is also implicated in oxidative damage to eye structures (Tok 2014), lowering of seizure thresholds (Lopez-Martin 2009; Kouchaki 2016; Cinar 2013: Azmy 2020) and the development of breast cancer due to an imbalance in internal physiologic oxidants and antioxidants (Yang 2021; Mortazavi 2018; Blask 2009).
Social Media
It has also become apparent that the excessive use of digital technology and social media in children can have adverse mental health effects including internet addiction, cyberbullying, deficient social skills, depression and lack of exercise. Uhls (2014) noted that five days at an outdoor education camp without screens improves preteen skills with nonverbal emotion cues. Studies have shown structural brain changes in children with excessive screen time (Hutton 2019), as well as those with internet addiction (Wang 2016; Hong 2013; Wang 2013; Weng 2012; Lin 2011).
Privacy
Privacy concerns of digital technology in schools are also emerging, and create a safety issue for children. A 2022 report “K-12 EdTech Safety Benchmark. National Findings Part 1. Dec 13, 2022. The findings “clearly show personal information safety risks to children and families are present and pervasive in the technology recommended and used by U.S. educational institutions, including: 1) Nearly all apps (96%) share children’s personal information with third parties, 78% of the time with advertising and monetization entities, typically without the knowledge or consent of the users or the schools, making them unsafe 2) School apps (23%) expose kids to digital ads, which creates a risk that personal student data is being sent into advertising networks, with no way for the public to inspect where it goes or how it’s used; more than half of those apps (13%) use retargeting ads, which use cookies, search and site history to serve up targeted advertising; this means even more personal student data is being sent into advertising networks to better serve the advertisers.”
In 2014, the SCCMA supported the California Medical Association resolution which called for re-evaluation and strengthening of wireless safety standards to consider non-thermal biological effects. (Ref 1) There was enough evidence then to call for precaution, and now even more scientific literature links wireless radiation to health risks. This is especially true for the most vulnerable members of our population, our children. (Moon 2020; Heindel 2015; Landrigan and Goldberg 2011; Weiss 2000). Standards have still not be updated to include biological nonthermal effects or effects on vulnerable populations such as children, pregnant women, the elderly or those with comorbidities.
Mitigation Measures
Legislators, government agencies and organizations are increasingly recommending reducing wireless and digital devices as a preventative health strategy. These include the Parliamentary Assembly Council of Europe, Russian National Committee of Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection, Austrian Medical Association, German Parliament, The Cyprus National Committee on Environment and Children’s Health, The Collaborative for High Performing Schools, The New Jersey Education Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics (Ref 22-37).
The development and use of digital technology creates a novel complex risk for children. Considering the burgeoning scientific evidence, outdated standards for radiofrequency radiation and variability of sensitivities in the population, precaution is warranted. Having a safe and healthy environment that promotes learning is essential for the performance and success of students. Positive outcomes in health and education have far reaching benefits and conversely negative outcomes affect all future generations and our society at large.
For these reasons, the SCCMA supports reducing exposures to radiofrequency radiation from wireless devices and encourages establishing safer school technology policies with regard to digital devices and infrastructure in order to promote the physical health, mental health and wellbeing of students and staff. Healthier children translate into healthier communities and a healthier society.
ll Best Practice Policy Recommendations to Improve Health, Safety and the Learning Environment for Students
Based on scientific research, attached addendums and references the SCCMA supports the following actions that can, singly or together, help to reduce wireless radiofrequency radiation exposures and create safer healthy learning environments in schools.
https://smartmeterharm.org/2023/08/06/california-santa-clara-county-medical-association-releases-recommendations-for-safer-technology-use-in-schools/
HOW IS THE GEOENGINEERING AND GLOBAL WARMING AGENDA GOING – EVERYTHING IS GETTING EXPOSED…
From Joel M. Moskowitz, Ph.D., DirectorCenter for Family and Community HealthSchool of Public HealthUniversity of…
Webinar 2006: Angels Still Don’t Play This HAARP Based on the book: Angels Don’t Play…
Environmental Film Festival Award Winning Film “Freequencies” by Seventeen-Year-Old Olivia Louise Curto A17-year-old film-maker from Ireland…
60 + years since Silent Spring: Where are we now?Endocrine-disrupting chemical exposures in early life,…
From Smart Meter Education Networkhttps://smartmetereducationnetwork.com/ Smart Meters Harm Your HealthHarm the EnvironmentCollect Data You Might…